Side-by-side comparison based on expert reviews and community consensus.
Hamilton Beach Sure-Crisp Air Fryer Toaster Oven
Best BudgetOur Place Wonder Oven
Most StylishPrice
$90-$100
$185-$325
Summary
Good Housekeeping's best-value pick at under $100, capable of fitting a 12-inch pizza and producing uniformly crispy wings and fries. Simple three-knob operation makes it the easiest to use on this list.
CNET's pick for best air-frying toaster oven with a retro design available in multiple colors. Matches dedicated air fryers on performance while adding a steam function that keeps food moist.
Pros
- Under $100 price point — best value on the market
- Fits a 12-inch frozen pizza despite compact size
- Produced uniformly melted cheese and evenly colored toast in GH lab tests
- Wings and fries crisped up quickly, evenly, and nicely
- Simple three-knob operation with auto-shutoff
- Air fry performance matched a dedicated PowerXL air fryer in CNET testing
- Steam function keeps food moist — unique feature in this category
- Excellent temperature consistency across all 8 cooking modes
- Compact footprint good for crowded kitchens
- Available in multiple colors with a fun retro aesthetic
Cons
- Mechanical dials less precise than digital controls
- Timer increments set in units of five with no individual minute markings
- Smaller capacity limits cooking for larger families
- Harder to clean than a traditional basket air fryer
- More expensive than comparable-sized competitors
- Newer product with less long-term durability data
Our take
For anyone who doesn't want to overthink it or spend over $100, the Hamilton Beach Sure-Crisp just works. It beat pricier models in GH's air frying tests — that's all you need to know.
If you care about how your kitchen looks and want a genuinely capable machine, the Wonder Oven delivers. The steam function is a legitimately useful differentiator you won't find on most competitors.
Buy
