Side-by-side comparison based on expert reviews and community consensus.
Breville Smart Oven Air Fryer Pro
Best Toaster Oven Style (No Nonstick)Ninja Air Fryer Max XL
Best Budget Ceramic OptionPrice
$350-$400
$110-$180
Summary
A full-size countertop oven with stainless steel interior racks — no nonstick basket in sight. Reddit's top pick for people who want coating-free air frying with maximum versatility.
Good Housekeeping's top-performing basket air fryer uses a ceramic nonstick interior instead of traditional PTFE — a meaningful step away from Teflon at a fraction of the price of glass alternatives.
Pros
- Stainless steel interior with wire racks — no nonstick coating on cooking surfaces
- Massive capacity handles whole chickens, large pizzas, and multi-rack cooking
- 13 cooking functions including air fry, roast, bake, broil, dehydrate, and proof
- Precise thermostat — consistently accurate temperature control
- Replaces toaster oven, air fryer, and nearly a full oven
- Ceramic nonstick interior — PTFE-free, a safer alternative to traditional Teflon
- Best-performing basket air fryer in Good Housekeeping's 50+ model test
- Reaches 450°F for Max Crisp and Air Broil modes
- Basket and tray are dishwasher-safe
- Held up to daily use over multiple years in long-term testing
Cons
- Expensive at $350+
- Takes longer to preheat than basket-style air fryers
- Harder to clean than a basket fryer — drippings fall to the bottom
- Large footprint requires dedicated counter space
- Air frying not as fast or crispy as dedicated basket fryers
- Still has a nonstick coating — just ceramic rather than PTFE
- Basket diameter is smaller than competitors at 5.5 quarts
- Slight scratching on removable tray noted after extended use
- Plastic exterior shell
Our take
If you cook for a family and want to ditch nonstick entirely, the Breville is the move. The stainless steel interior and wire racks mean nothing to chip or degrade, and it nearly replaces your wall oven.
Not fully coating-free, but the ceramic interior is a real upgrade over traditional nonstick. If you want the best cooking performance under $120 with reduced chemical concerns, this is your pick.
Buy
