Side-by-side comparison based on expert reviews and community consensus.
Breville Smart Oven Air Fryer Pro
Best Air Fryer Toaster OvenNinja Air Fryer Max XL
Best Traditional BasketPrice
$333-$350
$110-$180
Summary
The gold standard of air fryer toaster ovens — it toasts, bakes, broils, roasts, and air fries with near-oven-replacement capability. Serious Eats says you can't do better if you want a multi-function countertop oven.
Good Housekeeping's top-performing basket air fryer after testing 50+ models, consistently producing the crispiest chicken wings in the shortest time. A proven long-term performer that holds up to daily use for years.
Pros
- Replaces toaster oven, air fryer, and nearly a full wall oven for holidays and large batches
- Preheats fast and maintains precise, honest thermostat temperatures
- Sleek, consistent design that has held up over years of use
- Multiple cooking modes: toast, bake, broil, roast, air fry, dehydrate, and more
- Top pick from both Serious Eats and CNET for air fryer toaster ovens
- Consistently makes the crispiest, most golden chicken wings of any basket-style air fryer tested
- Max Crisp and Air Broil settings reach 450°F — higher than most competitors
- Ceramic nonstick interior has held up well over years of daily use
- Dishwasher-safe basket and tray for easy cleanup
- Includes broiling rack for extra browning
Cons
- Expensive at $333-$350
- Large cooking chamber makes it harder to achieve the same crust as a compact basket air fryer
- Air fry function not as powerful as dedicated basket-style air fryers
- Takes up significant counter space
- 5.5-quart basket diameter is smaller than some competing models
- Traditional nonstick coating (not glass or ceramic-only like some newer models)
- Some slight scratching on removable tray noted after long-term use
Our take
If you want to replace your toaster oven AND get air frying capability, the Breville Smart Oven Air Fryer Pro is the one to get. It's expensive, but it's the rare appliance that actually delivers on its multi-function promise.
For a classic basket air fryer that just works, the Ninja Max XL is the one to beat. Good Housekeeping has tested it for years and it still tops their charts — that kind of longevity is rare in this category.
Buy
