Side-by-side comparison based on expert reviews and community consensus.
Ninja Air Fryer Max XL
Best Traditional BasketTyphur Dome 2
Best Premium SplurgePrice
$110-$180
$340-$499
Summary
Good Housekeeping's top-performing basket air fryer after testing 50+ models, consistently producing the crispiest chicken wings in the shortest time. A proven long-term performer that holds up to daily use for years.
The most powerful basket air fryer available, with dual top-and-bottom burners that crisp two dozen wings in 14 minutes flat. WIRED's top overall pick and a Reddit favorite for anyone who wants the absolute best performance.
Pros
- Consistently makes the crispiest, most golden chicken wings of any basket-style air fryer tested
- Max Crisp and Air Broil settings reach 450°F — higher than most competitors
- Ceramic nonstick interior has held up well over years of daily use
- Dishwasher-safe basket and tray for easy cleanup
- Includes broiling rack for extra browning
- Dual top-and-bottom burners deliver unmatched speed — 24 wings crisped in 14 minutes
- Massive 5.6-quart basket with 12.6" x 12.6" surface area fits food in a single even layer
- PFAS-free ceramic nonstick cooking surface
- Smart app with 50+ recipes that can be queued directly to the machine
- Self-clean function burns grease off heating elements at 500°F
Cons
- 5.5-quart basket diameter is smaller than some competing models
- Traditional nonstick coating (not glass or ceramic-only like some newer models)
- Some slight scratching on removable tray noted after long-term use
- Expensive at $340-$499
- Large footprint at nearly 20" wide — takes up significant counter space
- Weighs 20 pounds — not easy to move around
- Requires the app to access some of its best features like self-clean
Our take
For a classic basket air fryer that just works, the Ninja Max XL is the one to beat. Good Housekeeping has tested it for years and it still tops their charts — that kind of longevity is rare in this category.
The Typhur Dome 2 is what happens when someone builds an air fryer without compromise. It's expensive and takes up counter space, but it out-air-fryers every other air fryer — if performance is your priority, nothing else comes close.
Buy
