Side-by-side comparison based on expert reviews and community consensus.
Borax + Sugar DIY Bait
Best DIY Natural OptionInTice Gelanimo Ant Bait
Best for Large or Stubborn InfestationsPrice
$3-$8
$25-$45
Summary
The original homemade ant bait that Reddit keeps recommending year after year. Mix borax with sugar and water (or honey) for a cheap, effective colony killer using the same active ingredient as Terro.
The top-ranked bait among serious ant-control enthusiasts and pest professionals. Outperforms Advion according to Reddit's dedicated ant-control community for heavy infestations.
Pros
- Extremely cheap — borax and sugar cost almost nothing
- Uses the same borax active ingredient found in commercial baits like Terro
- Highly customizable — adjust sugar-to-borax ratio for different ant species
- Recommended across multiple Reddit communities in different countries
- Ranked #1 ant bait by pest control enthusiasts on Reddit's dedicated ant-control community
- Gel formula works in hard-to-reach areas and voids
- Effective against a wide range of ant species including difficult infestations
- Professional-grade formula not commonly found in retail stores
Cons
- Requires mixing and monitoring — less convenient than pre-made stations
- No standardized dosage, so effectiveness can vary with your mix ratio
- Liquid mixture can dry out or attract other pests if left uncovered
- Harder to source than mainstream products — typically online only
- More expensive than consumer-grade baits
- Overkill for minor ant problems that Terro can handle
Our take
If you want to skip the store entirely, this works — borax is the same active ingredient in Terro, and you can make a huge batch for pennies.
This is the heavy artillery — if you've tried everything else and still have ants, Gelanimo is what the pros reach for first.
Buy
