A side-by-side comparison based on expert reviews and real community consensus.
Updated April 2026
The Brooklinen Luxe is the rare product that earns top marks from lab testers AND Reddit threads simultaneously — that cross-source consensus is hard to fake. The Luxome wins one specific battle (cooling) and wins it decisively, with a two-year owner endorsement and back-to-back Best Cooling picks from Sleep Foundation and CNET. But if temperature isn't your primary complaint, Brooklinen's durability, deeper color selection, and more forgiving return policy make it the smarter default buy.
The most consistently recommended sheets across expert labs and Reddit alike. Soft, durable 100% cotton sateen
Bamboo viscose sateen that sleeps noticeably cooler than cotton, testers report using it for two years with ze
This is the whole ballgame. Brooklinen's cotton sateen is breathable, but it doesn't actively move moisture away from your body. Luxome's bamboo viscose does — CNET's tester specifically noted they didn't feel body heat get trapped, and a real owner has used them for two years citing cooler sleep as the reason they stayed. If you run hot, this difference will change your sleep quality in a way no thread count ever will.
Good Housekeeping ran a 393-set lab test and Brooklinen came out ahead on durability and pilling resistance. Luxome's bamboo viscose is thinner by design — that's part of why it sleeps cool — but thinner means more delicate. Over dozens of wash cycles, Brooklinen's cotton construction holds its shape and texture more reliably. Sheets you have to baby aren't sheets you love.
Both CNET and the product's own cons section flag this: Luxome wrinkles badly out of the dryer. If you care about a made bed looking crisp — or you just don't want to iron your sheets — this is a genuine daily annoyance, not a minor footnote. Brooklinen comes out of the dryer looking like sheets. Luxome comes out looking like you slept in them before you put them on.
Sheets are personal — what feels luxurious to one person feels clammy or thin to another. Brooklinen's lenient return policy means you can actually sleep on them for a real trial period before committing. Luxome gives you 30 days, which sounds fine until you realize you need at least a few weeks of varied weather to know if the cooling benefit actually matters to you. The risk profile is just different.
Brooklinen Luxe vs Luxome Luxury, aspect by aspect.
Bamboo viscose wicks moisture — noticeably cooler
Lab-tested, pilling-resistant across many washes
Silkier, smoother — bamboo sateen wins on feel
Comes out of dryer looking clean and neat
17-inch pockets — fits most thick mattresses
19 color options across all standard sizes
Lenient return policy — low-risk buy