Side-by-side comparison based on expert reviews and community consensus.
Garmin Forerunner 165
Best BudgetGarmin Forerunner 265
Best OverallPrice
$199-$249
$350-$450
Summary
The Forerunner 165 is the most affordable way into Garmin's AMOLED ecosystem, offering solid GPS, in-depth training metrics, and a sleek design at a beginner-friendly price. Wirecutter and Tom's Guide both highlight it as a capable entry point.
The sweet spot in Garmin's lineup — full-featured AMOLED display, solid GPS, and advanced training metrics at a price that doesn't require a second mortgage. Consistently the most-recommended Garmin across Reddit communities for runners of all levels.
Pros
- AMOLED display at the most affordable price in Garmin's lineup
- Solid GPS accuracy for everyday running and training
- In-depth training metrics including VO2 max and training load
- Lightweight and comfortable for all-day wear
- AMOLED display with 454x454 resolution — same screen as the pricier 965
- Full training metrics including daily suggested workouts and race predictor
- Covers everything from 5K to marathon training
- Frequently found on sale around $350, making it accessible
Cons
- GPS signal acquisition slightly slower than competitors like Coros Pace 4 per Wirecutter testing
- Missing advanced features like topographical maps and multi-band GPS
- No music storage on base model (Music variant costs more)
- Lacks topographical maps found on higher-end models
- No music storage (need the 265 Music variant for that)
- Battery life shorter than Fenix or Forerunner 955/965 series
Our take
For new runners or anyone not ready to spend $350+, the Forerunner 165 gives you a real Garmin experience — AMOLED screen, training metrics, and reliable GPS — without the premium price tag.
If you only want one recommendation, this is it. The 265 hits the feature-to-price ratio better than anything else Garmin makes, and Reddit keeps coming back to it again and again.
Buy
