Side-by-side comparison based on expert reviews and community consensus.
Merrell Moab 3 Mid Waterproof
Best Budget PickSalomon Quest 4 Gore-Tex
Best for Heavy LoadsPrice
$120-$160
$180-$230
Summary
Nine years on Wirecutter's recommended list and a staple at REI for good reason. Reliable waterproofing, wide toe box, and a price that undercuts most competitors.
Wirecutter's top pick since 2018 and battle-tested over 46-mile hikes. Heavier than the X Ultra but delivers unmatched support when carrying a loaded pack on multi-day trips.
Pros
- 9 consecutive years recommended by Wirecutter — proven long-term reliability
- Wider toe box fits more foot shapes than La Sportiva or Salomon
- Waterproof without Gore-Tex markup — solid value
- Widely available at REI for easy in-person fitting
- Wirecutter's #1 pick for 9 consecutive years — rare editorial longevity
- Ample toe and heel protection with gusseted tongue to keep debris out
- Solid traction and ankle support under heavy pack weight
- Comfortable enough to wear in urban settings between trips
Cons
- Less ankle support than heavier boots under a loaded pack
- Sole not as grippy as La Sportiva or Salomon on wet rock
- Styling is utilitarian — not a crossover city boot
- Heavier than the X Ultra line — overkill for light day hikes
- Less flexible sole takes longer to break in
- Gore-Tex reduces breathability on hot summer days
Our take
The Moab is the Honda Civic of hiking boots — not flashy, not cutting-edge, but it just works for most people at a price that doesn't sting. If you're new to hiking or buying your first real boot, start here.
This is the boot you want when the trail gets serious and your pack gets heavy. The X Ultra is more fun for day hikes, but the Quest 4 is what you reach for when failure isn't an option.
Buy
