Side-by-side comparison based on expert reviews and community consensus.
NordicTrack Commercial 1750
Best PremiumVitalWalk Apollo 11 Elite
Best with InclinePrice
$1,200-$1,800
$400-$600
Summary
Wirecutter's top treadmill pick after testing 37 machines since 2017, and real users report using it daily once it's set up. Overkill for casual walkers, but unmatched if you want it to last a decade.
One of the few walking pads with 15% auto incline and a brushless motor, making it a serious fitness tool rather than just a step counter. Recommended for users who want a real workout.
Pros
- Wirecutter's top pick after testing 37 treadmills
- Doubles as a full treadmill with handrail for running
- Real users report daily use with no issues
- Full incline functionality available
- 15% auto incline for real fitness challenge
- 3.0HP peak power brushless motor for quiet, reliable operation
- Upright folding design saves floor space
- Mentioned positively in Reddit folding pad discussions
Cons
- Much bulkier and heavier than true walking pads
- Significantly more expensive than dedicated walking pads
- Requires more floor space — not ideal for small apartments
- Handrail must be down to limit speed to 4 mph walking pad mode
- Higher price than flat walking pads
- Upright storage design may not fit all spaces
- Less community data available compared to WalkingPad or Urevo
Our take
If you're serious about daily use and want something that won't die in two years, the NordicTrack Commercial 1750 is the only pick that has both expert consensus and real-world daily use reports behind it.
If flat walking feels too easy and you want actual cardio challenge, the VitalWalk Apollo 11 Elite's 15% incline is a genuine differentiator in this category.
Buy
