Side-by-side comparison based on expert reviews and community consensus.
Logitech MX Keys S
Best OverallLogitech Pop Icon Keys
Best CompactPrice
$100-$120
$50-$80
Summary
Consistently top-ranked by experts and loved by community users alike. Backlit keys, triple-device Bluetooth pairing, and a comfortable typing experience make it the go-to for productivity.
Wirecutter's top overall wireless pick for its fun typing feel, years-long battery life, and compact versatility. A great non-mechanical option for users who want portability without sacrificing quality.
Pros
- Pairs with up to 3 devices via Bluetooth or USB dongle
- Backlit keys with comfortable, well-spaced layout
- Top-rated typing experience among full-size wireless keyboards
- Works seamlessly across Mac and PC
- Years-long battery life — one of the best in class
- Compact design without sacrificing key comfort
- Versatile multi-device Bluetooth pairing
- Enjoyable, tactile typing feel for a non-mechanical board
Cons
- No mechanical switches — membrane feel won't satisfy enthusiasts
- Premium price compared to budget alternatives
- Larger footprint not ideal for minimal desk setups
- No backlighting, limiting use in dim environments
- Not ideal for users who need a number pad
- Playful aesthetic may not suit professional settings
Our take
If you want one wireless keyboard that does everything well without fuss, the MX Keys S is it — Wirecutter, RTINGS, PCMag, and Reddit all point to it, and that kind of consensus is rare.
Wirecutter called it the best wireless keyboard after testing 100+ options — the Pop Icon Keys punches above its weight for anyone who doesn't need a number pad or mechanical switches.
Buy
