Side-by-side comparison based on expert reviews and community consensus.
Bosch PS31-2A 12V Max Cordless Drill
Best Step-Up from BudgetRyobi 18V ONE+ Cordless Drill
Best Overall for BeginnersPrice
$99-$156
$129-$150
Summary
Tops performance charts for 12V drills despite its compact size — CNET called it 'dynamite, explosive performance in a small package.' Comes with two batteries and a carrying case, making it the best-equipped kit in its class.
The ONE+ battery ecosystem powers 260+ tools, so your first battery investment grows with you. Lightweight, ergonomic, and forgiving enough for total beginners while handling real tasks like drywall, lumber, and shelf-hanging.
Pros
- Topped performance scores across the board in CNET's 12V category tests
- Includes two 2.0 Ah batteries and soft carrying case
- 21-stage clutch for precise screw depth control
- Weighs just 2.14 lbs — comfortable for extended overhead work
- Battery-life indicator on the side so you know when to recharge
- 18V ONE+ battery works across 260+ Ryobi tools (lawnmowers, leaf blowers, etc.)
- Lightweight at 2.7 lbs with ergonomic grip that reduces hand fatigue
- Built-in LED light for working in dark spaces
- 750 in/lbs torque handles drywall, dimensional lumber, and shelf-mounting easily
- Backed by Home Depot's 3-year warranty
Cons
- 12V limits performance on large-diameter holes and heavy-duty tasks
- Battery can be tricky to remove until you get the hang of it
- More expensive than comparable 12V options
- Not suited for heavy-duty tasks like boring holes in concrete or dense hardwoods
- LED light could be brighter according to some testers
- Slips slightly when drilling into metal if not carefully positioned
Our take
The Bosch PS31 is the drill that surprises everyone who picks it up — it feels light but drives screws like a much bigger tool, and the two included batteries mean you're never waiting on a charge.
Ryobi is the drill I'd hand a first-timer without hesitation — it's the rare tool that's genuinely easy to use on day one but won't embarrass you two years in when your project list gets serious.
Buy
