A side-by-side comparison based on expert reviews and real community consensus.
Updated April 2026
The Smart Oven Air Fryer Pro scores higher across every major testing outlet and costs significantly less. The Joule's app is genuinely good — Serious Eats specifically praised its recipe library — but if you're not the type to browse chef-tested cooking sequences on your phone, you're paying a steep premium for hardware that's functionally identical. The BOV900BSS is the rare product that earns its 'best overall' label without asterisks.
The top pick from both Serious Eats and Good Housekeeping, this app-connected oven handles 13 cooking modes wi
The most consistently top-ranked countertop convection oven across every major testing source. Roomy interior,
The Joule's app isn't gimmicky smart-home theater — Serious Eats specifically called out its recipe library as one of the most fleshed-out of any connected oven. Multi-stage cooking sequences mean you can set a recipe and walk away while the oven adjusts temperature and mode automatically. But if you cook from memory or your own recipes, that library is shelf-ware you paid $150 for.
The Smart Oven Air Fryer Pro scores 92/100 versus the Joule's 88/100, and that gap reflects real-world testing depth. Serious Eats put the BOV900BSS through 12 pounds of fries and 24 pounds of chicken wings before crowning it. CNET gave it best-in-class broiled salmon. That's a broader, more rigorous testing record than the Joule has accumulated — and it matters when you're spending $300+.
The Joule starts at $500 and doesn't dip below it. The BOV900BSS can be found for $320 on sale, and even at its $500 ceiling it's the same price as the Joule's floor. That $150-plus difference buys a lot of groceries to cook in whichever oven you choose. Unless the app is a genuine priority, the BOV900BSS is the smarter financial decision by a wide margin.
Both products share the exact same weakness: air-fried wings aren't as crispy as a standalone air fryer. This isn't a knock on either one specifically — it's the physics of a large oven chamber versus a compact dedicated unit. If ultra-crispy air frying is your primary use case, neither of these is your answer. But for everything else — roasting, baking, broiling, dehydrating — both are excellent.
Breville Joule vs Breville Smart, aspect by aspect.
Top pick at Serious Eats, CNET, and Good Housekeeping
Chef-tested library, multi-stage sequences, autopilot
Best-in-class broiled salmon, cookies, chicken, pizza
Same quality available $150+ cheaper on sale
Both deliver here. 13 modes including proof, slow cook, dehydrate
Intuitive controls, no app dependency
Both deliver here. Wings less crispy than standalone air fryers
Years of top rankings, deep community trust on r/Cooking