Side-by-side comparison based on expert reviews and community consensus.
Epicurean Cutting Board
Best Dishwasher-Safe BoardOXO Good Grips Plastic Cutting Board
Best Budget PickPrice
$25-$60
$20-$40
Summary
The top pick for people who want a wood-like feel without the maintenance. Dishwasher-safe, lightweight, and nearly indestructible — Reddit's r/BuyItForLife community swears by them.
The best plastic board you can buy, according to Tom's Guide's hands-on testing. Food-grade hard plastic, well-constructed, and easy to sanitize — a practical workhorse for everyday prep.
Pros
- Completely dishwasher-safe — no oiling or special care required
- Lightweight and thin, easy to handle and store
- Made from compressed wood fiber — gentle on knife edges
- Praised specifically in r/BuyItForLife for lasting 'forever'
- Top-rated in Tom's Guide hands-on testing of multiple boards
- Dishwasher safe and easy to sanitize — ideal for raw meat prep
- Affordable and widely available
- Non-slip grip keeps it stable during use
Cons
- Not as visually premium as solid wood end-grain boards
- Can develop surface grooves over time with heavy use
- Less satisfying cutting feel compared to thick wood boards
- Plastic develops knife grooves over time that can harbor bacteria
- Not as knife-friendly as wood or rubber surfaces
- Less durable long-term compared to wood boards
Our take
For anyone who refuses to hand-wash their cutting board, Epicurean is the answer. It's the rare board that's both low-maintenance and genuinely long-lasting.
Plastic boards get a bad rap, but OXO's version is the one worth keeping. It's the board you actually use every day without worrying about it.
Buy
