Side-by-side comparison based on expert reviews and community consensus.
John Boos Block Cutting Board
Best Overall Wood BoardOXO Good Grips Plastic Cutting Board
Best Budget PickPrice
$60-$250
$20-$40
Summary
The gold standard in wood cutting boards, praised across Reddit communities for unmatched sturdiness and longevity. Maple, walnut, and cherry options available — all knife-friendly and built to last decades.
The best plastic board you can buy, according to Tom's Guide's hands-on testing. Food-grade hard plastic, well-constructed, and easy to sanitize — a practical workhorse for everyday prep.
Pros
- Repeatedly cited as 'sturdiest, most well made and long lasting' across multiple Reddit threads
- Available in top-tier woods like maple and walnut — both ideal for edge retention
- End grain and edge grain options available for different use cases
- Heirloom quality — can be resurfaced and re-oiled to extend life indefinitely
- Top-rated in Tom's Guide hands-on testing of multiple boards
- Dishwasher safe and easy to sanitize — ideal for raw meat prep
- Affordable and widely available
- Non-slip grip keeps it stable during use
Cons
- Requires regular oiling and hand-washing — not dishwasher safe
- Premium price point compared to plastic or bamboo alternatives
- Heavy, especially larger end-grain models
- Plastic develops knife grooves over time that can harbor bacteria
- Not as knife-friendly as wood or rubber surfaces
- Less durable long-term compared to wood boards
Our take
If you're buying one cutting board for life, this is it. Boos Blocks have a cult following for a reason — they're the board serious home cooks and professionals keep coming back to.
Plastic boards get a bad rap, but OXO's version is the one worth keeping. It's the board you actually use every day without worrying about it.
Buy
