Native Deodorant earns loyal repeat users, one commenter noted they “only use native now, have for the last couple years”, largely praising its “shea butter” base that makes it “super smooth and creamy to apply”. However, the community is far from unanimous: a recurring complaint is that “it permanently stained shirts and a Mountain Hardwear puff coat” due to its coconut oil formula, and multiple users flagged baking-soda-triggered rashes that sent them searching for alternatives. Even fans acknowledge a ceiling on its performance, with one user bluntly stating that “unlike aluminum antiperspirant, Native does not go beyond 24 hours very well”, making it a solid but imperfect transition for those leaving conventional deodorants.
What holds up
30+ scent options including fun limited editions like Jarritos Watermelon
Baking soda + tapioca starch absorb moisture effectively without aluminum
Vegan formula free of parabens and phthalates
Widely available at drugstores and affordable at ~$14
What to know
Can leave white marks on dark clothing
Gets gummy if reapplied multiple times without wiping down first
Not an antiperspirant, won't stop sweating
Expert verdict
I've been a longtime fan and user of Native deodorant. It's affordable, it's sold at most drugstores, and it works well.
Native is worth trying if you want an aluminum-free stick with a genuinely smooth, shea-butter texture and broad scent variety available at most drugstores, just apply it daily and keep it away from technical fabrics prone to oil staining.
Reddit users dealing with hyperhidrosis and heavy sweating consistently turn to Degree Advanced 72H MotionSense as a reliable option, with one South Florida commenter noting they use it after being “diagnosed with Hyperhidrosis at a young age” and finding “its helped a lot”. A user in r/hygiene highlighted the product's distinct formulation, pointing out it is “the only deodorant I've found in stores that uses a different form of aluminum”, making it a practical choice for people with sensitivities to aluminum zirconium tetrachlorohydrex. Those comparing it to pricier alternatives like Carpe found it delivers “the same active ingredients for substantially cheaper”, reinforcing its reputation as a no-nonsense, cost-effective option for people who need serious sweat protection.
What holds up
72-hour odor and sweat protection claim backed by real-user reports
MotionSense microcapsule technology releases fragrance during movement
Bargain price, one of the most affordable effective antiperspirants
Widely available at drugstores and grocery stores
What to know
Contains aluminum, not suitable for those avoiding it
Fruity-floral scent is polarizing; some find it too strong
Not ideal for those with sensitive skin
Expert verdict
It's advertised as 48-hour protection and it does just that, even after a hike/workout.
Good Housekeeping Beauty LabView sourceExpert verdict
Bargain-priced Degree is a great choice for active women thanks to its powerful odor and sweat protection.
All the degree 72 advanced stick deodorants work well. Just find a scent you like. I find that the women's versions have a softer scent that doesn't make you nauseous.
Degree Advanced 72H MotionSense stands out because it uses aluminum sesquichlorohydrate rather than the more common aluminum zirconium, offering effective sweat and odor control for people with hyperhidrosis or aluminum sensitivities at a fraction of the cost of specialty alternatives like Carpe.
Reddit users have had a strikingly mixed relationship with Dove 0% Aluminum, with some finding it a reliable everyday option, one user noting they use it “typically on regular days”, while others report troubling side effects. A user in r/Skincare_Addiction warned that “the discoloration began after about a week of use”, leading them to discard the product entirely, and another in r/Skincare_Addiction described burning sensations tied to the formula's zinc neodecanoate. Perhaps most critically for those switching from antiperspirants, a r/NaturalBeauty user who tested multiple aluminum-free alternatives found that with Dove 0%, they “eventually don't stink later in the day”, ultimately abandoning it for a competing brand.
What holds up
Moisturizing formula with glycerin soothes sensitive underarm skin
Glides on smoothly with no white residue on clothes
Wide range of scents with long-lasting staying power
Budget-friendly and widely available
What to know
Some shoppers find the scents smell too synthetic
Not an antiperspirant, won't prevent sweating
Odor protection may not hold up for heavy sweaters
Expert verdict
Dove is practically synonymous with moisture and this aluminum-free deodorant is no exception. Its moisturizing ingredients soothe the sensitive area, preventing irritation and redness.
After using this Dove 0%, I immediately noticed a difference and overall felt more refreshed and clean without having to worry about it being visible on my body or clothes.
This is my favorite deodorant. It keeps my sensitive skin smooth, protected, and it has an amazing long-lasting scent that stays all day and night.
Walmart reviewer via Good HousekeepingView sourceFrom the community
I only used this deodorant for 2 weeks, the discoloration began after about a week of use, and now I discarded it. I am no completely turned off on all dove deodorants now.
Dove 0% Aluminum works as a low-effort, skin-familiar daily deodorant for those who don't sweat heavily, but anyone prone to skin sensitivity or expecting all-day odor control should test it cautiously before committing.
Reddit users have a nuanced relationship with Secret Clinical Strength, many swear by its effectiveness, particularly when applied at night, with one r/hygiene commenter noting it “works better for me, especially if applied before bed”. For some, it has become a decade-long staple, though frustration creeps in as loyal users report they “keep discontinuing my favorite scents”. The cost is a recurring sticking point, one r/AskWomen user candidly admitted it was “sooooo expensive” before switching back to a standard antiperspirant with comparable results. Still, for those dealing with serious sweat and odor concerns, the higher aluminum concentration keeps it in a category where, for some, “clinical strength is the only deodorant that works”.
What holds up
Clinical-strength formula with 25% more aluminum than standard Secret
Up to 48-hour protection when applied at bedtime
Clean, fresh scent that isn't overpowering
No adverse skin reactions reported by testers with sensitive skin
What to know
Contains aluminum, not for those avoiding it
Requires bedtime application for maximum effectiveness
Not a complete sweat stopper, reduces but doesn't eliminate sweating
Expert verdict
It's not a magic cure to stop all sweating, but it does provide me with strong enough protection for daily use.
We found this standard roll-on bar to be the most effective bar we tested. It reduced her sweating all day, didn't need to be reapplied after a workout, and caused no adverse reactions.
For anyone who struggles with sweat-related embarrassment and has found regular antiperspirants falling short, Secret Clinical Strength earns its place as a long-term daily essential, with users sticking with it for over a decade specifically because nothing else delivers the same reliable dryness, especially when applied before bed.
Reddit users are sharply divided on Lume Whole Body Deodorant, with experiences ranging from loyal converts to cautionary tales. Some swear by its odor control across the whole body, one user noted that after “switching (and starting to work out pretty heavily) it works super well”, while another's partner “will only use it now” after struggling to find deodorants that work. But the product's chemistry doesn't agree with everyone: at least one user reported a “rash all over” requiring two months of doctor visits, and another found it “altered my body chemistry so I smelled worse than ever, even through the Lume”. The consensus is that Lume is highly body-chemistry-dependent, a genuine solution for some, a frustrating misfire for others.
What holds up
Designed for whole-body use: underarms, under-breasts, feet, groin
9 scent options plus unscented; available as stick or cream
pH-balancing mandelic acid is anti-fungal and helps with acne
Over 57,000 five-star Amazon reviews
What to know
Initial scent can smell unpleasant due to mandelic acid (fades quickly)
Didn't stretch as long as the brand's 72-hour claim in some tests
Cream formula requires finger application, which some find inconvenient
Expert verdict
It seemed very effective, and the tube allowed me to apply liberally and to use it all over my body. Plus, it did not stain my clothing!
Good Housekeeping Beauty Lab testerView sourceExpert verdict
With over 57,000 five-star reviews on Amazon and over 1,000 purchases in the last month, this whole body deodorant is an easy winner among Amazon reviewers.
I am pleasantly surprised at how well this works! This one actually keeps that under-boob (and other parts) dry!! This will be perfect for summer.
Amazon reviewer via Good HousekeepingView sourceFrom the community
I use a regular gel antiperspirant/deo underarms and the Lume under my boobs, apron belly, and thigh creases and this works really well for me. With the old formula, it does smell a bit like playdoh coming straight out of the tube, but that smell dissipates fairly quickly and doesn't transfer onto your body.
If your body chemistry is compatible, Lume can replace conventional deodorant entirely, even through heavy workouts, but the risk of skin reactions and a polarizing base scent make it worth patch-testing before committing to full-body use.
rabbit.reviews