Side-by-side comparison based on expert reviews and community consensus.
Hill's Science Diet
Best PremiumThe Farmer's Dog
Best Fresh Food DeliveryPrice
$60-$100
$3-$15/day
Summary
A vet-recommended staple that appears on every WSAVA-compliant list. Formulated with rigorous nutritional science and available in targeted formulas for specific health needs.
Fresh, human-grade dog food portioned to your dog's specific size, age, and weight — delivered to your door. CNET's top pick for delivery services and beloved by owners who want to skip kibble entirely.
Pros
- WSAVA-compliant with peer-reviewed nutritional research
- Broad range of prescription and over-the-counter formulas
- Consistently recommended by veterinarians
- Employs board-certified veterinary nutritionists
- Restaurant-quality ingredients with no fillers or preservatives
- Perfectly portioned meals tailored to your dog's profile
- 50% off first order makes it easy to trial
- CNET's top-rated dog food delivery service
Cons
- One of the pricier mainstream options
- Some dogs find the palatability lower than other brands
- Fewer 'natural' or grain-free options for owners who prefer those
- Significantly more expensive than kibble long-term
- Requires freezer storage and advance planning
- Subscription model — cancellation process can be cumbersome
Our take
Hill's is what vets actually feed their own dogs. If your dog has any health sensitivities or you just want zero guesswork, this is the safest premium pick.
If you have the budget and want to stop worrying about ingredient quality, The Farmer's Dog is the easiest upgrade you can make. Real food, no guesswork, and dogs go absolutely crazy for it.
Buy
