Side-by-side comparison based on expert reviews and community consensus.
Bocce's Bakery Dog Treats
Best Healthy TreatZuke's Mini Naturals
Best OverallPrice
$6-$12
$10-$18
Summary
Fewer than 10 ingredients, fun flavors like peanut butter-bacon and burgers-and-fries, and soft enough to break up for training. Both vets and CNET editors recommend these as a healthier indulgence.
The go-to training treat recommended by vets and Reddit alike. At just 2 calories per piece, they're soft enough to break into tiny bits and smell strong enough to keep any dog focused.
Pros
- Under 10 ingredients — some varieties have as few as 4
- Soft texture easy to break into small training-sized pieces
- Creative flavors dogs love including peanut butter-bacon and burger-and-fries
- Recommended by both vet experts and CNET editors
- Only 2 calories per treat — won't spoil appetite or cause weight gain
- Soft texture breaks easily into smaller pieces for precise portioning
- Strong smell that appeals to dogs and keeps them motivated during training
- Available in multiple flavors including chicken and peanut butter
Cons
- 6 oz bag goes quickly, especially for larger dogs
- Slightly pricier per ounce than basic training treats
- Not as widely available in physical stores as mainstream brands
- Zip-top bag seal can be faulty — may need to transfer to a separate container
- Soft texture means they can crumble in warm pockets
- Not ideal as a long-lasting chew — purely a training/reward treat
Our take
Bocce's hits the sweet spot between healthy and genuinely exciting for dogs. The short ingredient list satisfies health-conscious owners, and the creative flavors mean your dog will actually go crazy for them.
If you only buy one bag of dog treats, make it Zuke's. Vets love them, trainers swear by them, and Reddit recommends them constantly — that's a rare trifecta.
Buy
