Brooklinen Down Comforter vs The Company Store Legends Hotel Alberta Down Comforter

Fill power measures loft and insulating efficiency — higher means fluffier, lighter, and warmer per ounce of down. Brooklinen's 700 fill power Canadian duck down is a meaningful step above the Company Store's 600-650 European down, which matters when you're paying $400+ for the latter. You're getting objectively better insulation material from the cheaper comforter, which is a strange position for a 'luxury hotel' product to be in.

The Company Store's queen runs $400-$500. Brooklinen's all-season queen is $199. That $200 difference is hard to justify when Brooklinen has higher fill power, equivalent baffle-box construction, and a higher consensus score (88 vs. 80). The Company Store is asking you to pay a luxury premium for a product that underperforms on the headline spec. The only honest reason to pay more is the drop length and the hotel aesthetic — and you need to decide if that's worth it.

This is the one area where the Company Store has a concrete, practical advantage. A 15-inch drop means the comforter hangs significantly further over the sides of the bed, which eliminates the nightly tug-of-war that happens when two people share a standard comforter. Brooklinen doesn't advertise an oversized drop, so if you've ever woken up at 3am with your partner having stolen the whole thing, this feature alone might be worth the price of admission.

Multiple reviewers flag this — even the lightest warmth level from the Company Store runs warmer than you'd expect. For hot sleepers, this is a dealbreaker at $400+. Brooklinen's all-season weight was specifically praised by The Spruce for handling both hot and cold sleepers in the same bed. If you or your partner overheats at night, Brooklinen is the safer, cheaper, and better-reviewed choice.