A side-by-side comparison based on expert reviews and real community consensus.
Updated May 2026
The FUEL wins on almost every technical dimension: brushless motor longevity, hammer drill capability, and a 92 vs 83 consensus score from reviewers who've actually used both. But the brushed M18 pulls off something impressive — it has the highest torque rating of any 18V brushed drill and outperformed every competitor in its class by 20% in lab testing. The real tradeoff is this: the FUEL is a professional tool that handles masonry and metal without flinching, while the brushed M18 is the best value in heavy-duty drilling for anyone who doesn't need to punch through concrete.
The highest maximum torque rating (500 in-lbs) of any 18V brushed drill, and it crushed the competition in hig
The go-to drill for professionals who need serious power in a compact package. Dominates in torque, hammer dri
The FUEL is a hammer drill, meaning it delivers rapid percussive blows while rotating — that's what lets it chew through concrete and masonry. The brushed M18 is a drill/driver only, which means the moment you hit a concrete anchor or a brick wall, you're stuck. For most homeowners this never comes up. For anyone on a job site, it comes up constantly.
Brushless motors don't have physical contact points wearing down with every rotation, which means the FUEL runs cooler, draws less battery drain per task, and will outlast the brushed M18 by years of heavy use. For a weekend DIYer, this difference is nearly invisible. For a contractor running the drill 6 hours a day, it's the difference between a tool that lasts a decade and one that needs replacing in three years.
At $149-$179, the brushed M18 is already the most expensive 18V brushed drill in its class. The FUEL starts at $229 and can run to $329 depending on the kit. That delta buys you a brushless motor, hammer drill function, and AutoStop safety — genuinely valuable features. But if you're not using those features, you're paying a significant premium for capability that sits idle.
Drill bind-up — when a bit catches and the drill torques violently in your hand — sends thousands of people to the ER every year. The FUEL's AutoStop feature detects bind-up and cuts power before the drill wrenches your wrist. It sounds like a minor feature until it happens to you once. The brushed M18 has no equivalent protection, which matters more as hole sizes and material hardness increase.
Milwaukee M18 vs Milwaukee M18, aspect by aspect.
Both deliver here. 500 in-lbs — highest-rated brushed 18V drill
Wood, metal, concrete, and masonry
Brushless — cooler, longer-lasting, more efficient
Best-in-class performance at mid-range price
AutoStop prevents wrist injury on bind-up
Compact 7-inch body, same ergonomics, pro-grade feel
Charger supports both M18 and M12 — rare flexibility
92/100 — go-to drill for working tradespeople