A side-by-side comparison based on expert reviews and real community consensus.
Updated April 2026
The Ninja Foodi is genuinely the better grill — hotter, faster, smarter with its probe thermometer, and versatile enough to replace your air fryer too. But it costs three times as much, weighs 22 pounds, and dominates your counter. The Hamilton Beach was good enough that Serious Eats recommended it over grills twice its price, and for a solo apartment dweller who grills a few times a month, that's all the grill you need. The community agrees: Reddit loves the Ninja for families, but budget-conscious buyers consistently call the Hamilton Beach a steal.
Serious Eats' runner-up pick at a fraction of the price of premium models. The viewing window lid and adjustab
Does the work of six appliances, grill, air fryer, roaster, broiler, baker, and dehydrator, in one unit. The 5
The Ninja Foodi replaces six appliances — grill, air fryer, roaster, broiler, baker, dehydrator — in one unit. If you're already shopping for an air fryer, buying the Ninja instead means you're essentially getting the indoor grill for free. The Hamilton Beach does one thing: grill. That's not a knock, but if counter space is limited and you want to consolidate, the Hamilton Beach can't compete with that value proposition.
Epicurious testing found the Hamilton Beach took nearly twice as long to cook food as comparable premium grills. The Ninja's 500°F max temperature — among the highest of any indoor grill tested — closes that gap dramatically. When you're cooking a flank steak on a weeknight, waiting twice as long isn't a minor inconvenience, it's the difference between a quick dinner and a frustrating one.
The Ninja's built-in probe thermometer means you set a target temperature and the grill tells you when your meat is done — no cutting into it, no guessing, no overcooked chicken. The Hamilton Beach has no such feature; you're on your own with a meat thermometer or intuition. For anyone cooking thick cuts of pork, chicken, or steak regularly, this alone justifies a significant portion of the price difference.
At 22.4 pounds, the Ninja Foodi is not something you're tucking into a cabinet after every use — it lives on your counter permanently. The Hamilton Beach is compact at 16.75 x 12.25 inches and light enough to store easily. The tradeoff is cleanup: the Hamilton Beach's uncoated grate bottom is harder to scrub than coated surfaces, while the Ninja's components are more user-friendly to clean. Neither is perfect, but the Hamilton Beach wins on storage for anyone without dedicated counter real estate.
Hamilton Beach vs Ninja Foodi, aspect by aspect.
500°F max, among highest tested indoors
Flank steak done in ~10 minutes flat
Grills, air fries, roasts, broils, bakes, dehydrates
Dense grate whisks fat away, lid traps smoke well
Compact 16.75x12.25", fits in a cabinet easily
Coated surfaces, more forgiving to clean
Serious Eats-approved performance under $90
Built-in probe thermometer, intuitive control panel
rabbit.reviews