Side-by-side comparison based on expert reviews and community consensus.
Merrell Moab Mid Waterproof Hiking Boots
Best ValueSalomon Quest 4 Gore-Tex Hiking Boots
Best OverallPrice
$120-$160
$180-$230
Summary
Nine years on Wirecutter's recommended list and a staple recommendation at REI, the Merrell Moab is the most accessible quality hiking boot on the market. High arch support and proven waterproofing make it a reliable choice for most hikers.
Wirecutter's top hiking boot pick since 2018, offering ample toe and heel protection, solid traction, and a gusseted tongue. Consistently recommended across expert and community sources for all-day comfort and durability.
Pros
- Nine consecutive years on Wirecutter's recommended list
- High arch support suits a wide range of foot types
- Widely available at REI and other retailers for easy fitting
- Reliable waterproofing at a mid-range price
- Ample toe and heel protection for technical terrain
- Solid traction with reliable Gore-Tex waterproofing
- Gusseted tongue keeps debris out
- Long-term proven durability across years of testing
Cons
- Not as lightweight as trail-runner-style boots
- Less technical performance than La Sportiva or Salomon
- Some users find the toe box narrow
- Premium price point compared to budget options
- May feel stiff for hikers used to trail runners
- Heavier than ultralight alternatives
Our take
The Moab is the boot you recommend to someone who doesn't want to overthink it — widely available, well-priced, and battle-tested over nearly a decade of expert recommendations.
If you want one boot that does everything well and has stood the test of time, the Salomon Quest 4 GTX is it — nine years as Wirecutter's top pick isn't an accident.
Buy
