Side-by-side comparison based on expert reviews and community consensus.
Briggs & Riley Baseline Carry-On
Best OverallRimowa Original
Best Premium HardshellPrice
$500-$700
$700-$1,500
Summary
The most consistently praised luggage brand across Reddit and expert reviews alike. Lifetime unconditional warranty covers airline damage — no questions asked.
The most recognizable hardshell on the market with a cult following among frequent flyers. Aluminum construction survives brutal baggage handling and looks better with age.
Pros
- Unconditional lifetime warranty covers airline damage and complimentary repairs
- Higher proportion of usable interior space than competing spinners per Wirecutter testing
- Every detail — zippers, wheels, handles — built to highest standards
- Wrinkle-resistant suit compartment for business travelers
- Iconic aluminum or polycarbonate construction handles extreme baggage handler abuse
- Develops character over time — scratches and dents tell travel stories
- Lifetime guarantee and global repair network
- Compact enough for carry-on with serious interior organization
Cons
- Significantly more expensive than most competitors ($500-$700+)
- Heavier than ultralight options like Travelpro Maxlite
- Overkill for occasional or budget travelers
- Very expensive ($700-$1,500+)
- Aluminum version is heavy compared to polycarbonate competitors
- Scratches and dents are inevitable — some find this distressing rather than charming
Our take
If you want luggage you'll never have to buy again, Briggs & Riley is the answer. The warranty alone makes the premium price worth it for anyone who travels more than a few times a year.
Rimowa is the one piece of luggage people keep for decades and brag about. If you want something that signals serious traveler and actually backs it up with durability, this is it.
Buy
