rabbit.reviews
Best for Color Lovers

The Company Store Company Cotton Classic Cool Cotton Percale Sheet Set

Same crisp percale performance as the top pick but with a vibrant color palette that makes bedtime genuinely exciting. A Wirecutter editor called it a 'mood-booster' that made her 'couldn't wait to go to bed.'

$120-$200
Pros
  • Standout color palette described as a genuine 'mood-booster'
  • Cool cotton percale weave ideal for hot sleepers
  • Wirecutter-tested and recommended alongside their top pick
  • Classic smooth construction comparable to premium competitors
Cons
  • Fewer color options than some lifestyle brands
  • Not as long-tested as the L.L.Bean pick
  • Wrinkle-free sateen version available but percale line is more limited
Why we recommend it

If L.L.Bean's color options feel boring to you, this is your answer — same quality tier, way more personality. The fact that a Wirecutter tester switched from white sheets to these and never looked back says everything.

Wirecutter

I didn't understand what a mood-booster colorful sheets could be at bedtime, but suddenly, in that 2022 testing, I couldn't wait to go to bed.