Side-by-side comparison based on expert reviews and community consensus.
Greenies Dental Treats
Best Dental TreatStella & Chewy's Freeze-Dried Treats (Just Jerky Bites & Crav'n Bacon)
Best Overall Dog TreatPrice
$10-$30
$10-$20
Summary
Greenies are the go-to recommendation for owners who want treats that double as dental care. Vets recommend them, dogs love them, and they come in both dog and cat formulas.
Consistently the top pick across dog training and reactive dog communities. High-protein, freeze-dried formula makes these irresistible even for the most distracted or anxious dogs.
Pros
- Clinically proven to reduce tartar and plaque buildup
- Available in dog and cat formulas (including catnip flavor for cats)
- Dogs and cats genuinely enjoy eating them
- Multiple size options for different breeds
- Extremely high palatability — works for reactive and high-strung dogs
- Multiple formats (jerky bites, bacon bites, wild weenies) for variety
- Freeze-dried process preserves nutrients and flavor
- Small enough to use as training treats without overfeeding
Cons
- Higher calorie count than small training treats
- Some dogs eat them too fast, reducing dental benefit
- Not suitable as a high-frequency training reward due to size and calories
- Can cause digestive upset in sensitive dogs if given too many
- More expensive than budget treat options
- Strong smell can be off-putting to some owners
- Not ideal for dogs with poultry or beef sensitivities
Our take
Greenies are one of the few treats that actually do something useful beyond just tasting good. If your pet's dental health matters to you — and it should — keep a bag of these on hand.
If you need one treat that works for training, high-value rewards, and picky dogs, Stella & Chewy's is the name that comes up again and again on Reddit. It's the gold standard.
Buy
