Side-by-side comparison based on expert reviews and community consensus.
Casio PX-S3100
Best Digital PianoFaber & Faber My First Piano Adventure (Book A)
Best Beginner Method BookPrice
$500-$700
$8-$15
Summary
A slim, full-weighted 88-key digital piano that gives young learners a real piano feel without the cost of an acoustic. Recommended in r/piano as a serious starter instrument worth growing into.
The most-recommended curriculum for young beginners, designed for ages 5-6 but widely used with 4-year-olds. Short, playful lessons keep tiny attention spans engaged.
Pros
- Full 88 weighted keys teach proper finger technique from the start
- Slim, space-saving design fits in most homes
- Grows with the child — no need to upgrade for years
- Recommended directly in r/piano for a young child's first instrument
- Designed specifically for very young students with simple songs and exercises
- Fun and entertaining format suited for preschoolers
- Recommended by multiple piano teachers on r/pianoteachers and r/piano
- Short practice sessions (3-5 minutes) match a 4-year-old's attention span
Cons
- Higher price point than toy keyboards or entry-level options
- May be overkill if the child loses interest quickly
- Availability can vary by region — not always easy to find in stores
- Technically marketed for ages 5-6, so some 4-year-olds may find it slightly advanced
- Requires a parent or teacher to guide lessons — not self-directed
- Physical book only; no interactive digital component
Our take
Don't waste money on a toy keyboard — the Casio PX-S3100 is the kind of instrument a 4-year-old can start on and still be playing at 14. Weighted keys matter for building proper technique from day one.
If you're starting a 4-year-old on piano, this book is the closest thing to a consensus pick — multiple piano teachers and parents on Reddit swear by it for this exact age.
Buy
