Side-by-side comparison based on expert reviews and community consensus.
Seed & Sprout Stainless Steel Popsicle Molds
Best Stainless SteelTovolo Classic Pop Molds
Best OverallPrice
$35-$55
$20-$30
Summary
The go-to pick for parents avoiding plastic entirely. Reddit parents praise these for durability and a bonus: toddlers love playing with them even outside the freezer.
Wirecutter's top pick after testing 31 molds and making nearly 200 ice pops. Silicone construction peels away cleanly, and the built-in drip tray keeps things mess-free.
Pros
- 100% stainless steel — no plastic or silicone contact with food
- Durable enough to double as toddler play items
- Works really well per direct owner experience
- Good choice for parents avoiding BPA and plastic entirely
- Silicone flexes away from frozen pops without running under warm water
- Compact tray with effective drip catcher reduces mess
- Dishwasher safe — unlike many competitors
- Consistent pop shape across all six molds
Cons
- Stainless steel can make pop removal harder without a warm water rinse
- More expensive than silicone or plastic alternatives
- Less widely available than mainstream brands
- Plastic molds can occasionally be finicky to remove a pop from
- Classic shape won't excite kids who want novelty designs
- Mid-range price compared to budget silicone options
Our take
If plastic-free is non-negotiable for you, Seed & Sprout is the clear community answer. No one else in the stainless steel category gets mentioned with this kind of enthusiasm.
If you want one mold that just works every time, this is it. Wirecutter tested more popsicle molds than anyone should have to, and the Tovolo won on shape, ease of removal, and drip control.
Buy
