A side-by-side comparison based on expert reviews and real community consensus.
Updated May 2026
These two tops are solving completely different problems. The Aerie Voop wins on versatility, value, and sheer cleverness — that neckline shape creates cleavage without looking stuffed, and at $30–$50 it's hard to argue with. But it completely falls apart for fuller busts, where the shallow cups and non-bra sizing become a real liability. The Abercrombie Curve Love exists specifically for the D–F cup crowd that every other push-up top ignores, and for that audience it's genuinely the better product — even with its limited color range and lack of padding.
Built for D–F cups with smaller band sizes, this underwire top lifts and supports without the bulk of traditio
Aerie's Voop neckline is a cult favorite for creating cleavage with natural-looking, removable padding. It's a
The Abercrombie Curve Love is one of the only push-up tops on the market explicitly sized for D–F cups with smaller bands. The Aerie Voop uses standard S–XL sizing with shallow cups — a combination that works beautifully for smaller busts but creates real slippage and coverage issues for anyone above a C cup. This isn't a minor fit nuance; it's the entire reason to choose one over the other.
Aerie's Voop cut creates cleavage through the geometry of the neckline itself, not just by shoving padding under your chest. It's a smarter design for smaller busts who want lift without bulk. The Abercrombie takes the opposite approach — underwire and structured cups that physically lift and support. For a D cup, that structure isn't optional; it's what makes the top functional rather than decorative.
The Aerie comes with removable padding that enhances the Voop effect — you can take it out if you want, though losing it means you can't replace it. The Abercrombie has no lining or padding at all, which means less modesty in the cups when wet. For a D–F cup, the underwire does the heavy lifting anyway, but it's worth knowing you're not getting any coverage assistance from the fabric itself.
At $30–$50 with seasonal colors and patterns, the Aerie Voop is the better buy if you're shopping casually. Abercrombie's Curve Love sits at $47–$55 with limited color options — you're paying for the engineering, not the aesthetics. If you're a D–F cup, that tradeoff is worth it. If you're not, you're overpaying for a top that wasn't designed for you anyway.
Abercrombie & vs Aerie Crinkle, aspect by aspect.
Voop neckline creates natural cleavage perfectly
Underwire and wide straps built for D–F
Stretchy crinkle fabric, no tight swimsuit feeling
$30–$50 with seasonal colors and patterns
Bra-sized cups give predictable, accurate fit
Both deliver here. No lining — less coverage when wet
Rotating seasonal prints, trendy crinkle texture