Side-by-side comparison based on expert reviews and community consensus.
Columbia Watertight II
Best BudgetRains Raincoat
Best for StylePrice
$60-$90
$100-$200
Summary
A reliable, affordable rain jacket that punches above its price class with solid waterproofing and packability. A go-to recommendation for casual hikers and commuters who don't want to overspend.
A fashion-forward raincoat with PU coating, welded seams, and serious waterproofing that doesn't look like hiking gear. Proven over 4+ years by real users across multiple climates.
Pros
- Affordable price point makes quality rain protection accessible
- Packable design for easy storage in a bag or backpack
- Omni-Tech waterproof breathable construction
- Wide availability in many sizes and colors
- PU coating with welded seams provides very high waterproofing
- Fashionable design suitable for urban and travel use
- Lightweight and packable for everyday carry
- Proven durability over 4+ years of real-world use
Cons
- Not as durable or breathable as 3-layer Gore-Tex options
- DWR finish degrades faster than premium membranes
- Fewer technical features than higher-end competitors
- Less breathable than Gore-Tex options for active use
- Not ideal for high-output hiking or backpacking
- Limited technical features like pit zips or helmet-compatible hoods
Our take
For under $80, the Columbia Watertight II delivers dependable rain protection without the premium price tag — it's the smart pick if you're not ready to commit to a $200+ jacket.
If you want to stay dry without looking like you're about to summit a mountain, Rains is the move — it's the rare raincoat that works equally well in Amsterdam or New York.
Buy
