Side-by-side comparison based on expert reviews and community consensus.
Helly Hansen Rain Jacket
Best Mid-RangePatagonia Pluma
Best LightweightPrice
$100-$300
$299-$349
Summary
Consistently ranked in the second tier alongside Marmot by the hiking community — solid waterproofing at a more accessible price than Arc'teryx. A trusted Scandinavian brand with serious weather credentials.
The most versatile of Patagonia's shell lineup — ultralight, packable, and stylish enough for everyday use. r/BuyItForLife calls it the best all-rounder of the three top Patagonia options.
Pros
- Recommended by r/hikinggear as a top second-tier option after Arc'teryx
- Strong brand reputation for genuine waterproofing in harsh conditions
- Multiple models available across price points (Loke, Moss, Mandal)
- More accessible price than Arc'teryx while still performing well
- Ultralight and packable — easy to carry on any trip
- Most versatile of Patagonia's shell lineup per r/BuyItForLife community
- Patagonia lifetime warranty included
- Works well for both hiking and everyday urban use
Cons
- Less community buzz than Patagonia or Arc'teryx in hiking forums
- Some models are heavier and less packable than competitors
- Fit can run large depending on the model
- Less durable than heavier shells like the Beta AR
- Not ideal for sustained heavy downpours or alpine conditions
- Higher price than the Torrentshell for a lighter jacket
Our take
Helly Hansen is the brand that serious sailors and Norwegian fishermen trust — that's not marketing, that's heritage. If Arc'teryx is out of budget, HH is the next honest step down.
If you want one jacket that goes from trail to town without looking like you're about to summit Everest, the Pluma is the move — lighter and more versatile than the Torrentshell.
Buy
