Side-by-side comparison based on expert reviews and community consensus.
GE Profile PFE28KYNFS
Best ValueMaytag MRFF4236RZ
Best BudgetPrice
$1,800-$2,400
$1,100-$1,600
Summary
Tom's Guide's best refrigerator overall, with 27.7 cubic feet of space, smart features, and a design that punches above its price. GE and GE Profile are consistently called 'safe bets' across Reddit communities.
RTINGS calls it a no-frills 36-inch French door fridge with good overall temperature uniformity and solid produce preservation. For buyers who want performance without paying for premium branding, Maytag delivers.
Pros
- 27.7 cubic feet — one of the largest capacities in its class
- Smart features and well-thought-out internal storage layout
- GE brand consistently praised for reliability and repairability on Reddit
- Widely available parts and authorized service coverage
- Good temperature uniformity per RTINGS lab testing
- Solid produce preservation performance for the price
- 36-inch standard depth maximizes storage capacity
- Lower price point than Bosch or GE Profile
Cons
- Not as quiet as Bosch — noticeable compressor noise reported
- Standard depth means it protrudes further than counter-depth models
- Smart features add complexity that can fail over time
- Few frills — no smart features, basic interior design
- Not as quiet as Bosch or premium competitors
- Less brand prestige and fewer premium finish options
Our take
If you want the most fridge for your money without gambling on reliability, GE Profile is the answer — it's the brand appliance repair techs recommend most.
Maytag is the unglamorous pick that just works — if you don't need smart features or a designer look, this is where your money goes furthest.
Buy
