Side-by-side comparison based on expert reviews and community consensus.
Concept2 RowErg
Best OverallWaterRower Natural
Best Water RowerPrice
$900-$1,100
$1,100-$1,500
Summary
The undisputed gold standard for rowing machines, used by competitive athletes worldwide. Unmatched durability, resale value, and workout quality make it the top pick across every serious rowing community.
The most aesthetically stunning rowing machine available, with a water flywheel that mimics the feel of rowing on open water. A favorite for home gyms where looks and feel both matter.
Pros
- Industry standard for competitive and recreational rowers alike
- Exceptional durability with minimal maintenance required
- Holds resale value better than any other rowing machine
- Air-resistance flywheel delivers the most authentic rowing feel
- Gorgeous handcrafted wood design that doubles as furniture
- Water resistance closely mimics the feel of on-water rowing
- Quieter than air-resistance machines like the Concept2
- Strong community and brand reputation among fitness enthusiasts
Cons
- Higher upfront cost compared to budget options
- No built-in screen or subscription workout content
- Louder than magnetic or water resistance machines
- Not ideal for competitive training or improving personal splits
- Requires periodic water tank maintenance and refilling
- More expensive than comparable air-resistance rowers
Our take
If you only read one thing: buy the Concept2. Reddit's rowing community is unanimous, Wirecutter agrees, and it's the only machine that holds its value for resale. Everything else is a compromise.
If the Concept2's industrial look doesn't fit your living space, the WaterRower is the next best thing — it's genuinely beautiful and the water resistance feels closer to real rowing than air.
Buy
