Side-by-side comparison based on expert reviews and community consensus.
ASICS Novablast 5
Best for VersatilityHoka Clifton
Best Cushioned OptionPrice
$130-$160
$130-$145
Summary
Called the best beginner shoe by multiple Reddit users, with one completing a 36-mile ultrarun in them. Tom's Guide also names it their top beginner pick for 2026.
Hoka's most beginner-accessible shoe, recommended across multiple Reddit threads for its maximal cushioning that protects joints during early training. Softer and more forgiving than most competitors.
Pros
- Explicitly named 'best beginner shoe IMO' by a Reddit user who ran a 36-mile ultrarun in them
- Tom's Guide ranks it #2 overall and #1 for beginners in 2026
- Energetic, bouncy ride that makes early runs more enjoyable
- Durable enough to grow with you as fitness improves
- Maximal cushioning reduces impact stress on knees and joints — ideal for new runners
- Mentioned positively across multiple beginner-focused Reddit threads
- Lightweight despite the thick midsole
- Excellent for slower daily miles and easy outings per WIRED
Cons
- Bouncier ride may feel unstable for runners with balance issues
- Slightly higher price than entry-level options
- Less widely available for in-store fitting than Brooks
- Some Reddit users suggest Hokas are better suited to experienced runners
- Very thick sole can feel unstable on uneven surfaces
- Less versatile for speed work or tempo runs
Our take
The Novablast 5 punches above its beginner label — it's bouncy enough to stay fun on easy runs but protective enough to handle real mileage. This is the pick if you want a shoe you won't outgrow quickly.
Ignore the Reddit comment saying Hokas are 'for experienced runners' — the Clifton specifically is a plush, low-intensity daily trainer that's perfect for beginners who want maximum joint protection.
Buy
