Side-by-side comparison based on expert reviews and community consensus.
ASICS Gel-Kayano
Best OverallSaucony Guide
Best Runner-Up StabilityPrice
$140-$160
$120-$140
Summary
The most consistently recommended stability shoe for flat feet across Reddit communities. Built for heavy overpronators with maximum arch support and plush cushioning for long runs.
A well-cushioned stability shoe that Wirecutter testers called 'the best of Hokas without the dead hollow feel.' Recommended by Reddit runners alongside Brooks and ASICS as a reliable flat-feet option.
Pros
- Top recommendation for heavy overpronation across multiple Reddit communities
- Strong medial post and arch support designed specifically for flat-footed runners
- Plush cushioning holds up over long distances
- Available in wide sizes for broader flat feet
- Praised by Wirecutter testers for cushioning that feels responsive, not dead
- Recommended in Reddit flat-feet threads alongside Brooks and ASICS
- Available in wide sizes for broader flat feet
- More rocker-feel geometry encourages natural forward movement
Cons
- Heavier than neutral shoes, not ideal for speed work
- Can feel squishy at faster paces according to Wirecutter testers
- Premium price point compared to other stability options
- Guide 18 received mixed reviews — Wirecutter recommends sticking with Guide 17
- Some testers reported hot spots during initial break-in
- Less community consensus than Kayano or Adrenaline for flat feet specifically
Our take
If you have flat feet and overpronate, the Kayano is the shoe Reddit keeps coming back to — it's the closest thing to a consensus pick in a category full of opinions.
The Saucony Guide doesn't get as much Reddit hype as the Kayano or Adrenaline, but Wirecutter's testing and multiple community mentions make it a legitimate alternative — especially if you want a more responsive ride.
Buy
