Side-by-side comparison based on expert reviews and community consensus.
Altra Running Shoes (Torin/Paradigm)
Best Wide Toe BoxNew Balance 880 (Wide)
Best OverallPrice
$130-$160
$140-$160
Summary
Altra's foot-shaped toe box is the widest in mainstream running — designed from the ground up for wide feet, not retrofitted. Zero-drop platform suits natural runners.
The most consistently recommended wide-foot running shoe across Reddit communities. Available in multiple widths up to 4E, with a genuinely wider last — not just extra material.
Pros
- Foot-shaped toe box is the widest available in mainstream running shoes
- Zero heel-to-toe drop promotes natural foot strike
- Recommended across multiple Reddit wide-foot communities
- Works well with toe spacers and orthotics due to roomy fit
- Available in multiple widths (2E, 4E) with a genuinely wider sole, not just a wider upper
- Well-cushioned for long runs and marathon training
- Highly durable and consistent across versions
- Trusted by wide-foot runners across multiple Reddit communities
Cons
- Zero-drop takes adjustment period — can strain calves and Achilles initially
- Not ideal for runners needing higher heel drop for Achilles issues
- Fewer stability/motion-control options compared to Brooks or ASICS
- Not the most exciting or responsive ride for faster workouts
- Wide sizes may have limited colorway options
- Can feel heavy compared to lighter trainers
Our take
For wide-forefoot runners especially, Altra is the brand built specifically for you. The toe box isn't just wide — it's shaped like an actual foot, which makes a real difference on long runs.
If you have wide feet and want one shoe that just works, the NB 880 is it. Reddit runners with wide feet return to it again and again, and New Balance's wide sizing is the real deal.
Buy
