Side-by-side comparison based on expert reviews and community consensus.
New Balance 880 (Wide)
Best OverallTopo Athletic Running Shoes
Best Natural FitPrice
$140-$160
$120-$150
Summary
The most consistently recommended wide-foot running shoe across Reddit communities. Available in multiple widths up to 4E, with a genuinely wider last — not just extra material.
Topo's naturally shaped toe box sits between Altra's extreme width and standard wide shoes — great for wide-forefoot runners who want a more conventional heel drop.
Pros
- Available in multiple widths (2E, 4E) with a genuinely wider sole, not just a wider upper
- Well-cushioned for long runs and marathon training
- Highly durable and consistent across versions
- Trusted by wide-foot runners across multiple Reddit communities
- Naturally shaped toe box accommodates wide forefeet without extreme zero-drop
- More conventional heel drop options than Altra (5mm-10mm depending on model)
- Highly comfortable for wide feet per Reddit community recommendations
- Lighter and more responsive feel than max-cushion options
Cons
- Not the most exciting or responsive ride for faster workouts
- Wide sizes may have limited colorway options
- Can feel heavy compared to lighter trainers
- Smaller brand with less availability in stores
- Fewer model options compared to Brooks, New Balance, or Hoka
- Less community data and long-term durability reviews available
Our take
If you have wide feet and want one shoe that just works, the NB 880 is it. Reddit runners with wide feet return to it again and again, and New Balance's wide sizing is the real deal.
Topo is the underrated middle ground: wider than most brands without going full zero-drop like Altra. If Altra's drop scares you but standard wides still pinch, Topo is your answer.
Buy
