Side-by-side comparison based on expert reviews and community consensus.
Schlage Encode Plus
Best for Security-Conscious BuyersYale Assure 2
Best OverallPrice
$150-$230
$150-$250
Summary
ANSI Grade 1 deadbolt — the highest residential security rating — with built-in Wi-Fi and Apple Home Key. Trusted by locksmiths for decades and works great without any hub.
The most consistently recommended smart lock across Reddit communities. Reliable hardware, supports Matter/Z-Wave/Zigbee, and plays nicely with every major smart home platform.
Pros
- ANSI Grade 1 deadbolt — highest residential security certification
- Built-in Wi-Fi means no hub required
- Supports Apple Home Key for tap-to-unlock
- Can be used as a regular lock even without smart features enabled
- Supports Matter, Z-Wave, and Zigbee for broad ecosystem compatibility
- Works with Apple Home/HomeKit, Alexa, Google Home, and SmartThings
- Compact, sturdy build with excellent companion app
- Apple Home Key support for tap-to-unlock via Apple Watch
Cons
- Bulkier exterior design compared to minimalist competitors
- Apple Home Key is the primary ecosystem; Android experience is less polished
- Higher price than budget options
- Some configurations require a separate hub for Z-Wave/Zigbee
- Wi-Fi module may need to be purchased separately depending on variant
- Higher price point than budget alternatives
Our take
When the r/Locksmith community recommends something, you listen. Schlage's hardware quality is in a different class from most smart lock brands, and the Encode Plus delivers that with modern smart features.
If you only read one recommendation, it's this: the Yale Assure 2 is the community consensus pick, full stop. It's reliable, ecosystem-agnostic, and you won't regret it.
Buy
