Side-by-side comparison based on expert reviews and community consensus.
Garmin Forerunner 265
Best Overall for RunnersGarmin Forerunner 55
Best Budget PickPrice
$349-$399
$150-$200
Summary
The go-to running watch recommended across every runner subreddit. Combines serious GPS accuracy, deep training metrics, and multi-day battery in a watch that doesn't sacrifice smartwatch usability.
The no-frills entry point into serious GPS running at around $160. Wirecutter recommends it as the best budget running watch, and Reddit beginners consistently praise it as more than capable for tracking workouts.
Pros
- Solid GPS accuracy with fast signal acquisition
- Multi-day battery life far exceeds Apple Watch
- Deep running metrics including training load and recovery
- Good balance of smartwatch features and running-specific tools
- Excellent battery life for the price point
- Accurate GPS tracking for runs and cycling
- Syncs with Strava and other popular platforms
- Pared-down interface is easy to learn
Cons
- More expensive than entry-level Garmin options
- Garmin app ecosystem less polished than Apple/Google
- Bulkier design than fashion-forward smartwatches
- Missing advanced training metrics found on higher Forerunner models
- No music storage or contactless payments
- Basic smartwatch notifications only
Our take
If you're serious about running, this is the watch to get. Reddit runners who've switched from Apple Watch consistently say the metrics and battery life are on another level.
Don't overthink it for your first running watch — the Forerunner 55 does everything a beginner to intermediate runner needs at a price that won't sting if you decide running isn't for you.
Buy
