Side-by-side comparison based on expert reviews and community consensus.
Blue Lizard Sensitive Mineral Sunscreen SPF 50
Best Mineral SunscreenSupergoop Unseen Sunscreen SPF 40
Best for Everyday WearPrice
$15-$29
$18-$38
Summary
WIRED's top pick after real-world testing on multi-hour hikes — the mineral sunscreen with the least visible white cast of any untinted formula tested. Hydrating like body lotion, no added fragrance, and reef-safe.
The sunscreen that doesn't feel like sunscreen — a clear, weightless gel that disappears into skin with zero white cast, no sunscreen smell, and a perfect makeup-primer finish. Works for all skin tones and types.
Pros
- Least visible white cast of all mineral body sunscreens tested by WIRED
- Hydrating, lotion-like texture that isn't sticky or greasy
- No added fragrance — ideal for sensitive skin
- Held up well during 3-hour outdoor hikes in real-world testing
- Reef-safe mineral formula (zinc oxide + titanium dioxide)
- Completely invisible on all skin tones — no white cast whatsoever
- No sunscreen smell — safe for office or social settings
- Gel-like texture creates a perfect base for makeup
- Antioxidant blend protects against free radicals
- Fragrance-free, vegan, reef-friendly, dermatologist-tested
Cons
- Still has a slight white cast like all untinted mineral sunscreens
- Higher price (~$15-$29) compared to drugstore chemical options
- Thicker consistency may not suit those who prefer ultra-lightweight formulas
- Only 40-minute water resistance — not ideal for swimming or heavy sweating
- Higher price point (~$18-$38 depending on size)
- Less hydrating than lotion-based formulas — may not suit very dry skin
Our take
Blue Lizard is what you reach for when you want mineral protection without the chalky paste penalty. It's the rare mineral sunscreen that sensitive-skin people and outdoor athletes can both agree on.
Supergoop Unseen is the gateway drug for people who hate wearing sunscreen. The gel-like formula genuinely looks and feels like nothing on your skin, which means you'll actually wear it every day — and that's the whole point.
Buy
