Side-by-side comparison based on expert reviews and community consensus.
Brooks Cascadia 19
Best All-AroundNew Balance Fresh Foam X Hierro v9
Best ValuePrice
$150
$120-$160
Summary
Named best all-around trail shoe by iRunFar and praised for exceptional traction, stability, and comfort across every terrain type. The reliable workhorse that handles everything from technical mountain runs to muddy singletrack.
Maximum cushioning at a price that regularly dips below $120, with 4.1-4.3 star ratings across hundreds of REI reviews. A rare combination of plush comfort and trail-ready protection without the premium price tag.
Pros
- Named Best All-Around Trail Running Shoe by iRunFar
- Exceptional traction and stability on technical terrain
- Moderate 6-8mm drop works for a wide range of runners
- Tested on technical mountain runs and ultra-distance hikes
- 30mm+ stack height maximum cushioning for long-distance comfort
- Men's version regularly available from $119 — strong value
- 4.1-4.3 stars across 400+ combined REI reviews
- Solid traction and protection for varied trail conditions
Cons
- Not the lightest option for race-day use
- Less cushioning than max-stack competitors like Speedgoat
- Some runners find the fit slightly narrow
- Less brand prestige than Hoka or Salomon in trail running community
- Heavier than lighter-weight trail options
- Fit can run narrow for some runners
Our take
The Cascadia is the shoe you recommend to someone who doesn't want to overthink it — it's been the gold standard all-rounder for years and the 19 keeps that streak alive.
The Hierro v9 is the trail shoe you recommend when someone wants Speedgoat-level cushioning but can't stomach the price — it punches well above its weight class.
Buy
