Side-by-side comparison based on expert reviews and community consensus.
NICETOWN 100% Blackout Curtains
Best Overall BlackoutSmartWings Smart Motorized Curtains & Shades
Best Smart/MotorizedPrice
$25-$50
$100-$400+
Summary
The most consistently recommended blackout curtain across Reddit communities. Available in multiple sizes and colors, with triple-weave construction that delivers true cave darkness when installed wider and higher than the window frame.
CNET's top pick for smart window coverings in 2026, with an extensive selection of custom shades and broad smart home compatibility. Control via Alexa, Google Home, or Apple HomeKit with scheduling built in.
Pros
- Mentioned positively across multiple Reddit communities including r/sleeptrain, r/Nightshift, and r/homeownerstips
- Triple-weave blackout construction blocks nearly all light
- Available in a wide range of lengths, widths, and colors
- Affordable price point on Amazon with easy ordering
- CNET's top-rated smart blind after testing 10 competing products
- Extensive custom sizing and fabric selection
- Compatible with Alexa, Google Home, Apple HomeKit, and SmartThings
- Battery-powered — no hardwiring required for most setups
Cons
- Light can still leak from sides if not tacked to wall or installed with extra width
- Fabric can feel synthetic/plasticky compared to linen options
- May not suit design-forward interiors looking for a premium aesthetic
- Significantly more expensive than standard curtains
- Custom ordering means longer lead times
- Smart home hub may be required for full scheduling and automation features
Our take
If you want blackout curtains and don't want to overthink it, buy NICETOWN. Reddit has been recommending these for years across sleep, nightshift, and home improvement communities — that kind of sustained word-of-mouth is hard to fake.
If you want to automate your windows, SmartWings won CNET's head-to-head test against 10 competitors. The custom sizing options and smart home ecosystem support make it the most practical motorized option for most homes.
Buy
