Side-by-side comparison based on expert reviews and community consensus.
Keychron Q5 Max
Best for EnthusiastsLogitech MX Keys S
Best OverallPrice
$150-$200
$100-$120
Summary
The top pick for mechanical keyboard enthusiasts who want wireless done right. Keychron's Max series is the most-recommended brand across Reddit keyboard communities for quality wireless builds.
The go-to wireless keyboard for productivity, with backlit keys, three-device Bluetooth pairing, and a comfortable full-size layout. Consistently tops both expert and community recommendations.
Pros
- Highly regarded in keyboard enthusiast communities on Reddit
- Available in multiple sizes (Q1, Q2, Q5 Max) to suit different layouts
- Strong wireless performance with quality mechanical switches
- Recommended by both RTINGS and Reddit communities
- Backlit keys that are well-spaced and comfortable to type on
- Pairs with up to three devices via Bluetooth
- Full-size layout with number pad for productivity
- Consistently recommended across expert and community sources
Cons
- Higher price than entry-level wireless keyboards
- Heavier than typical office keyboards due to build quality
- May be overkill for casual typists
- Premium price point compared to budget alternatives
- Not ideal for gaming use cases
- Heavier and less portable than compact alternatives
Our take
Keychron is the brand Reddit's keyboard community trusts most, and the Q Max series is their best wireless offering — premium build, great switches, and no compromises on wireless performance.
If you want one keyboard that does everything well for work, this is it. The MX Keys S is the rare product that Reddit and Wirecutter agree on — buy it without overthinking.
Buy
