Side-by-side comparison based on expert reviews and community consensus.
Lodge Chef Collection 12 Inch Cast Iron Skillet
Best OverallSmithey No. 12 Cast Iron Skillet
Best PremiumPrice
$30-$60
$160-$200
Summary
The go-to recommendation across Reddit and expert sites alike. Delivers evenly browned steaks, crisp cornbread, and eggs that slide right out — at a price that's hard to argue with.
The smoothest, most refined cast iron skillet you can buy new. WIRED's tester says it beats even vintage Griswolds — the gold standard of cast iron.
Pros
- Lightest of all inexpensive skillets tested by Wirecutter
- Performs well across searing, baking, and eggs
- Widely available and backed by decades of reliability
- Comfortable handle and large helper handle for maneuvering
- Exceptionally smooth polished interior — better food release than most cast iron
- Lighter than comparable premium brands relative to pan size
- Heirloom-quality build praised by both experts and community
- Charleston, SC-made with meticulous craftsmanship
Cons
- Rougher factory seasoning compared to premium brands like Stargazer or Smithey
- Still heavy at ~8.5 lbs for the classic version
- Requires consistent seasoning maintenance
- Notably heavier than Stargazer and Field according to community feedback
- Premium price puts it out of reach for casual cooks
- Overkill for someone just starting with cast iron
Our take
Lodge is the answer when someone asks where to start with cast iron. It's the most recommended skillet across every forum and review site, and it just works.
Smithey is what you buy when you want the absolute best and don't mind paying for it. The polished interior is in a different league from mass-market pans.
Buy
