Side-by-side comparison based on expert reviews and community consensus.
Lowa Renegade GTX Mid
Best for Heavy LoadsSalomon Quest 4 Gore-Tex Hiking Boots
Best OverallPrice
$220-$280
$180-$230
Summary
A Reddit community favorite alongside Asolo for serious backpackers who need ankle support under heavy loads. Consistently mentioned in the same breath as the best boots money can buy.
Wirecutter's top pick since 2018 and consistently praised across Reddit for comfort, support, and waterproofing. Ample toe and heel protection with solid traction makes these the go-to for most hikers.
Pros
- Repeatedly recommended across r/hiking and r/hikinggear for durability and reliability
- Gore-Tex waterproofing with excellent ankle support for loaded carries
- Premium construction from a brand with decades of reputation in the hiking community
- Available in wide widths for harder-to-fit feet
- Wirecutter's #1 pick for 8+ consecutive years since 2018
- Ample toe and heel protection with solid traction and support
- Gusseted tongue keeps debris out on rough trails
- Gore-Tex waterproofing that holds up over years of use
- Praised across Reddit and expert sites for comfort and fit
Cons
- Expensive compared to mainstream options
- Requires break-in time before comfortable on long days
- Heavier than trail runners or lightweight hiking shoes
- Overkill for casual day hikers on easy terrain
- Newer Salomon models reportedly don't match the quality of older versions per Reddit users
- Premium price point compared to budget options like Merrell Moab
- May feel stiff for casual day hikers who prefer lighter footwear
Our take
Lowa's Renegade is the boot serious backpackers reach for when they need something that won't quit on a 10-day trip with a 50-pound pack. It's a workhorse that earns its price.
Eight years as Wirecutter's top pick isn't luck — these boots genuinely fit more feet and handle more terrain than anything else at this price. If you're buying one pair, buy these.
Buy
