Side-by-side comparison based on expert reviews and community consensus.
CRAFTSMAN V20 4-Tool 20V Combo Kit
Best for New HomeownersRYOBI 18V ONE+ 6-Tool Combo Kit (P1819)
Best Budget Power Tool KitPrice
$189-$239
$299-$349
Summary
Drill, impact driver, reciprocating saw, and task light with two batteries for around $189-$239 — Craftsman's V20 platform delivers near-pro performance at a price that won't scare off first-time buyers.
Six cordless tools, two batteries, and a bag for $349 — the ONE+ platform's 300+ compatible tools make this the best entry point for budget-conscious DIYers. Backed by a 3-year warranty.
Pros
- Four essential tools cover the vast majority of homeowner tasks
- Includes two batteries and charger — ready to use out of the box
- Lifetime warranty on hand tools; 3-year on power tools
- Available at Lowe's for easy in-store pickup and returns
- Competitive pricing — often on sale under $200
- Six tools included: drill, impact driver, recip saw, circular saw, multi-tool, and work light
- ONE+ platform compatible with 300+ Ryobi cordless products
- Includes both 1.5Ah and 4Ah batteries for flexibility
- 3-year manufacturer's warranty
- Significantly lower price than DeWalt or Milwaukee equivalents
Cons
- V20 platform less expansive than DeWalt 20V or Milwaukee M18 ecosystems
- Some Reddit users report quality has declined since Stanley Black & Decker acquisition
- Brushed motors on base models reduce longevity vs. brushless alternatives
- Task light less useful than a circular saw for serious projects
- Best suited for light to medium-duty jobs — not for heavy construction
- Brushed motors (not brushless) on most tools reduce efficiency vs. premium kits
- Battery platform not compatible with Ryobi 40V outdoor tools
- Customer service has been reported as difficult to reach by some users
Our take
Craftsman is the sweet spot between budget Ryobi and premium DeWalt. The V20 platform is solid, the tools perform well for typical homeowner tasks, and you can find it at Lowe's without hunting for deals.
For light-to-medium DIY work, Ryobi's ONE+ ecosystem is unbeatable value. You're not getting pro-grade power, but the sheer breadth of compatible tools means you'll never need to buy a second battery platform.
Buy
